Comments on: Are Bicycle Helmets Holding Us Back? https://momentummag.com/bicycle-helmets-holding-us-back-2/ smart living by bike Mon, 01 Jan 2024 21:55:24 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.7.2 By: j duffield https://momentummag.com/bicycle-helmets-holding-us-back-2/#comment-114561 Sun, 17 Feb 2019 12:22:28 +0000 https://momentummag.com/?p=27445#comment-114561 i had a serious crash and if not for my helmet i would be dead or braindead….

]]>
By: Frank Dimon https://momentummag.com/bicycle-helmets-holding-us-back-2/#comment-112361 Sat, 22 Dec 2018 22:03:14 +0000 https://momentummag.com/?p=27445#comment-112361 I ride my bike weekly in the summer time, I feel naked without wearing one. My helmet is black/bright green neon stripes. I think it helps drivers see me from afar: I always recommend choosing bright colors over black helmets. To me, I look and feel more professional on the road: Where I live I see more truckers and I ride with a life jacket on a long bridges at farm roads. Watch out for alligators…I’m just saying. 🙂

]]>
By: Jimmy https://momentummag.com/bicycle-helmets-holding-us-back-2/#comment-109035 Sun, 23 Sep 2018 21:16:44 +0000 https://momentummag.com/?p=27445#comment-109035 I ride my bike in the Florida about 2 to 3 times a week about 10 miles at a time. I have tried using helmets and it greatly reduces my enjoyment of biking. I would choose not to bike if I had to wear a helmet.

]]>
By: Finn https://momentummag.com/bicycle-helmets-holding-us-back-2/#comment-104936 Mon, 07 May 2018 18:44:22 +0000 https://momentummag.com/?p=27445#comment-104936 In reply to Miguel.

Great comment? Are you the One Cyclist In Lisbon?

]]>
By: Finn https://momentummag.com/bicycle-helmets-holding-us-back-2/#comment-104935 Mon, 07 May 2018 18:32:35 +0000 https://momentummag.com/?p=27445#comment-104935 In reply to AP.

Yes, in the event of a serious collision a helmet may save your life. But the benefits far outweigh the risk! Cycling without a helmet is more convenient, might make you ride safer, and it encourages more people to bike! And when more people bike, drivers become more aware and the danger is far reduced!

The likelihood of a serious collision is low enough that it shouldn’t even be considered. I’m not scared to fly on a plane, why should I be concerned about riding my bike? Driving is actually far more dangerous than we realize. I’m certain that in my life I will experience a nasty car crash.

I don’t have to pay for gas, insurance, or fares, and I’m not putting damage on the roads with a 2-ton cage.
I would still ride my bike even if it was unsafe, because the exercise and the freedom keeps me healthy and I feel great!

If helmets aren’t required, then more people bike. And when more people bike, it helps the city and more people enjoy the above benefits!

If there’s one thing I want, it’s healthy, happy cities. Cycling is a big part of that, so the fewer helmets, the better!

]]>
By: Finn https://momentummag.com/bicycle-helmets-holding-us-back-2/#comment-104934 Mon, 07 May 2018 18:05:18 +0000 https://momentummag.com/?p=27445#comment-104934 In reply to Emily.

Good for you! I wear a helmet because it’s mandatory where I live, and I don’t want to be hassled by people “why aren’t you wearing a helmet”? But I’m tempted now…

]]>
By: Richard Burton https://momentummag.com/bicycle-helmets-holding-us-back-2/#comment-91506 Fri, 14 Apr 2017 08:05:00 +0000 https://momentummag.com/?p=27445#comment-91506 In reply to AP.

As someone interested in the health of young people, which is the biggest threat to their health, obesity caused by lack of exercise, or injuries from playing, including cycling? Given that cycle helmets have killed children, and there is no proven case of a helmet saving a life, and that we are suffering an obesity crisis which will shorten millions of lives, the answer is clear.

Regular cyclists, those most exposed to the risk, live on average two years longer and suffer less from all forms of illness, so how can something likely to make you live significantly longer be dangerous? As one medical researcher said “If the benefits of cycling could be bottled, it would be the most popular medicine in the world.”

The myth of helmet effectiveness is just that, a myth based on bad science which has been disproved many times, but is still parotted by helmet zealots who refuse to even look at the evidence.

]]>
By: Richard Burton https://momentummag.com/bicycle-helmets-holding-us-back-2/#comment-91505 Fri, 14 Apr 2017 07:55:08 +0000 https://momentummag.com/?p=27445#comment-91505 A very comprehensive article which sums up the situation very well. The laws, promotion and propaganda for helmets is based on bad science, but it has been accepted as fact for so long that it is almost impossible to change perceptions, the so-called “persistence of myths” effect. It doesn’t matter how much real science proves that helmets don’t work, people revert to their original belief.

There are two types of evidence about cycle helmets; short term, small scale, rated low for reliability on international scales of reliability, and long term, large scale, rated much more reliable on the same scales. The first shows massive benefits, while the second shows either no benefit or an increase in risk with helmet wearing. The media endlessly report the first and ignore the second, leading most people to believe that helmets are effective.

You might be interested in my MSc Dissertation on the subject of cycle helmets “Do cyclists have an exaggerated perception of the effectiveness of cycle helmets and the risks of cycling?” http://www.fietsberaad.nl/index.cfm?lang=en&repository=Do+cyclists+have+an+exaggerated++perception+of+the+effectiveness+of++cycle+helmets+and+the+risks+of+cycling

]]>
By: rww https://momentummag.com/bicycle-helmets-holding-us-back-2/#comment-91503 Thu, 13 Apr 2017 23:21:23 +0000 https://momentummag.com/?p=27445#comment-91503 Well my helmet does not hold me back, it just protects my head.

]]>
By: Emily https://momentummag.com/bicycle-helmets-holding-us-back-2/#comment-91034 Tue, 28 Mar 2017 03:48:37 +0000 https://momentummag.com/?p=27445#comment-91034 Yeah I require my 8 year old daughter to wear one but the rest of us don’t. When we go on family bike rides my 13 year old daughter isn’t wearing a helmet, my 15 year old daughter isn’t, I’m not, and neither is my husband but my 8 year old daughter is. I told both of them that when they turned 13 that don’t have to wear helmets. My husband and I had really long debates about this, and I said they don’t need one. He is a Doctor so he thinks that they should but they don’t. So that my opinion

]]>