Comments on: North America vs. Europe: Who Has the Best Plan for City Bikers? https://momentummag.com/north-america-vs-europe-who-has-the-best-plan-for-city-bikers/ smart living by bike Wed, 29 Jan 2014 19:07:31 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.7.2 By: MrT https://momentummag.com/north-america-vs-europe-who-has-the-best-plan-for-city-bikers/#comment-481 Wed, 29 Jan 2014 19:07:31 +0000 http://momentummag.com/news/features/north-america-vs-europe-who-has-the-best-plan-for-city-bikers/#comment-481 I’m a bicyclist, not a biker. Or just a guy on a bicycle. But I’m not a biker.

]]>
By: David https://momentummag.com/north-america-vs-europe-who-has-the-best-plan-for-city-bikers/#comment-275 Thu, 16 Aug 2012 08:02:23 +0000 http://momentummag.com/news/features/north-america-vs-europe-who-has-the-best-plan-for-city-bikers/#comment-275 ” But different from North America, the Netherlands and Denmark both had a history of cycling and indeed, after World War II, the bicycle was the only mode of transport most people could afford. ”

Wrong! North America absolutely did have a history of cycling. Look at this image of Rochester, New York, from 1904. http://i.imgur.com/7J4dM.jpg

Zoom in to see many bicycles locked to bike racks, the sides of buildings, and street poles. I count at least 15; some faster cyclists may be missing from the picture because of the long exposure time.

The modern view for comparison: http://goo.gl/maps/JMpSS

Rochester is now as car-dominated and transitless as most small American cities, but clearly at one time had a strong, practical cycling culture.

Now that the automobile is the only viable transportation option in most of America, I can certainly understand why one would assume it had always been this way, but it’s inaccurate writing. I wish articles like this would stop perpetuating this falsehood. The dominance of the car is a recent change, and only now that the bicycle has been completely marginalized does it seem like it was never an option. It’s not that we never had a cycling culture, it’s that our cycling culture was destroyed.

]]>